Sunday, September 20, 2009

The Evils of Social Networking

"He that is good for making excuses is seldom good for anything else." -Benjamin Franklin

The issue of social networking is a very controversial issue, made so by the terrible tragedies surrounding it. These websites, such as MySpace and Facebook, have become very popular among young people and increasingly with the older generation as well. Unfortunately, instances in which children fall prey to predators lurking on said websites have become more common as well. Parents everywhere are concerned that these websites allow predators to access their children more easily. Meanwhile, the owners of these websites seem to want to ignore this issue. Naturally, there has been a general outcry over the their lack of responsibility. Hypocrisy? Most assuredly.

Let us for a moment examine the screwdriver: a common tool, often necessary for even the simplest of tasks. One of these is most likely present in almost every American home. There are no limits on who can buy them. There are no regulations on how they should be used. Why would there be? Now, let us picture this simple tool in the hands of a murderer. Suddenly that screwdriver looks pretty sharp, doesn't it? The fact is that any tool can be used in ways that are improper, or in some cases illegal. Should we limit access to screwdrivers? Perhaps require a background check, and a two-day waiting period?

I think we can all agree that this sounds pretty ridiculous. Yet for some reason, people always want to impose limits on the tools available to us. The creators of MySpace did not make a haven for child-molesters. They made a tool. The function of this particular tool is communication, nothing more. Who we communicate with is not decided by the tool, it is decided by us. How we use the screwdriver is not decided by the screwdriver. It's a simple concept that is not grasped by angry parents across the country. Why, you ask? Responsibility.

If you cut yourself with a knife, who do you blame? The knife? Probably not. If you poke yourself with a needle, do you sue the needle for being too sharp? Hey, you might win! But again, probably not. If you find out that your child is the victim of an internet predator, who do you blame? Suddenly, it's far more serious. Obviously, the predator is to blame, but who else is guilty? The predator would not have reached your child if not for the internet. Clearly, the internet should be held responsible, right? Well, not exactly. The internet is a tool. Much like the knife, if you don't use it right, you might get cut. So who is to blame? The child? Maybe, but then the child really can't be expected to know any better, especially if they are very young. In the end, the responsiblity falls on the parents.

The parents paid for the access to the internet. The parents failed to teach their child about the dangers of communicating with people who they did not know. The parents allowed their child to use a website which allowed the predator access to the child. And now that it's happened, will the parents step forward and take the blame? Will they accept that they have indirectly caused this harm to their child? Probably not. They will point fingers in every direction they can. The website is just the most convenient target. Excuses fly everywhere as the parents attempt to lay the blame on someone else, and because of that lack of responsibility the tool must be limited. The knife is made blunt, the needle is bent, and suddenly the CIA is looking into your criminal record when you go to buy a screwdriver. Sound funny? Give it time.

4 comments:

  1. Wow! Very well said! I loved how you began with a quote from a very influential historical figure. The way you compared the internet as a tool to a screwdriver. Basically I agree that personal responsibility is what is needed in this aspect. I mean all your comparisons are just the thing. Our parents taught us right from wrong, they taught us to be careful with the knife, and although they didn't go as far as telling us not to kill people with a screwdriver, they did teach us not to run with one in our hands because we could "poke your eye out". So if parents could teach us not to talk to strangers and all other dangers in this world it is also their responsibility to communicate the dangers in the internet to thier children. As for adults who fall into these negative situations and claim there is no warning... well common sense comes in handy every now and then.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Very impressive post. Your use of examples such as screwdrivers and needles really highlighted your stance. It is true that the internet and social networking is a tool and really can not make decisions on what to access and what no to. As many other people from class have stated it is the user of the tool who takes the responsibility.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Wow. very well put John. I like that you bring up the point of the internet being a "tool" and if people use it responsibly, then all is well.

    ReplyDelete